Latest News | November 1st, 2026

Heather McClure is a Managing Partner at Helio Risk and has some interesting thoughts on Ai & Captives.

To maximise leverage for captive coverage and give parent companies a strategic advantage, leaders must consider the risks and opportunities associated with emerging technologies. Here we examine the benefits of AI in three industries – insurance, healthcare, and construction, consider its risks and suggests ways organisations, supported by their captives, can undertake mitigation strategies.

Insurance industry benefits and risks

Insurance companies already use artificial intelligence (AI) in various insurance operations:

  • Underwriting: Underwriters use AI to increase accuracy of risk assessment by analysing historical data to identify patterns and predict risk ahead.
  • Claims: Insurance companies can handle large volumes of claims by scaling operations related to intake and adjusting.
  • Customer Service: Most people have experienced customer service chatbots trained to respond to frequently asked questions and offer solutions to common situations.
  • Fraud Detection: AI can flag specific data in applications or claims often signaling possible fraud.

Insurance companies risk data inaccuracy when any flaw in a complicated algorithm is used. Poor data quality can lead to improper claims or underwriting decisions. AI can incorporate bias influenced by factors such as credit score, education level, income, occupation and homeowner status, penalising low-income buyers. This could fall foul of unfair trade practice laws and other legal standards, especially when data is not used in accordance with industry regulations.

Healthcare industry benefits and risks

A National Institutes of Health review of 44 studies Benefits and Risks of AI in Health Care: Narrative Review found medical benefits of AI in healthcare included prediction, prevention and control of various risks and diseases as well as leading to better data-driven decisions within the health care system. Several uses for surgery were cited including robotic, telesurgery and AI-powered surgical mentorship.

AI also demonstrates economic and social benefits for patients, including reduction in post-treatment expenditures, cost saving through early diagnosis clinical trials and patient empowerment through wearable devices and other technology.

An elevated risk in healthcare is that, in improperly trained hands, AI can perpetuate human discrimination and bias captured within electronic health records, leading to further dissemination of incorrect advice. Human medical staff and chatbots can then give misleading or false medical advice. Further, to arrive at authoritative conclusions, AI systems require massive amounts of patient data to draw conclusions, leaving systems vulnerable to attack or data breaches.

Construction industry benefits and risks

AI systems can process huge volumes of data from past projects and ongoing work to identify risk factors early and suggest adjustments, including managing supply chains for large-scale projects. Engineers can now use generative AI to help plan materials and simulate outcomes for projects long before breaking ground.

Applications for site monitoring and safety are particularly useful in construction as AI can detect hazards and track safety issues before an accident happens on site. Further, AI tools can analyse architectural and engineering plans to catch defects early, reducing costly rework.

In the construction industry, it is easy to see how AI architectural or engineering plans using incorrect data could lead to disastrous design flaws that would pose safety concerns.

Mitigating AI risk

Risk management controls paired with internal audit functions play a critical role in mitigating risks posed by AI systems in all industries. Priorities at a governance level should include:

  • Developing appropriate AI use policies and procedures for the organisation;
  • AI system analysis and testing to determine whether conclusions reached are consistent with other data sources;
  • Regulatory compliance being actively assessed and maintained;
  • Monitoring of internal controls; and
  • Potential biases are considered based on the data input and population.

Internal audit support of an AI program is key. The internal audit team can help ensure financial, operational and compliance risks are being effectively addressed.

While there has been no US federal legislation on AI to date, industry associations and some state governments are seeking to provide guidance to supplement organisations’ responsible use of AI.

For the insurance industry, the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) voted to adopt the Model Bulletin on the Use of AI Systems by Insurers on December 4, 2023. This focuses on how insurers will govern the development/acquisition and use of certain AI technologies.

States are also developing standards. For example, on July 11, 2024, the New York State Department of Financial Services (NYDFS) published a circular stating insurance companies are expected to develop, implement and maintain a written program (an ‘AIS program’) for the responsible use of AI systems that make, or support, decisions related to regulated insurance practices, specifically focused on underwriting and pricing insurance policies and annuity contracts.

The AIS program should be based on a recognised risk management framework and document the insurer’s risk identification, mitigation, and internal controls for AI systems at each stage of the AI system life cycle. 

In healthcare, multiple resources, including the World Health Organization, (WHO) have released publications listing key regulatory considerations on artificial intelligence for health. In the US, the National Institutes of Health (NIH) has collected data regarding safety and risk associated with AI in healthcare. Global Regulatory Frameworks for the Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in the Healthcare Services Sector – PMC.

Captive insurance coverage

By integrating AI, companies can increase safety, streamline operations, enhance accuracy, reduce fraud, improve customer satisfaction and ultimately drive better business outcomes. There is no doubt this technology is here to stay and will be a common tool in nearly every sector of business.

Captives can continue to stand at the forefront of insuring evolving risks that are not easily underwritten in the commercial market. Providing coverages for exclusions, differences in conditions and even full lines of some risks created by expanding AI is where captives demonstrate their highest usefulness. As cyber coverage paved the way over the past two decades in partnership with captives, AI will continue along that path and give businesses their best opportunity for creating comprehensive risk financing programmes.